Approaches and Procedures for Assessing Judges Competence in Islamic Society

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Assistant Professor of History of Islamic Culture and Civilization, Department of Islamic Studies, University of Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources, Gorgan, Iran

2 Assistant Professor, Political Science, Department of Theology, Law and Islamic Education, Faculty of Humanities, Golestan University(Gorgan)

Abstract

Merit-based selection for positions, especially within the judiciary, is considered as a paramount strategies for promoting good governance and advancing a modern Islamic civilization. To attain this objective, leveraging the invaluable experiences of Islamic civilization is of utmost significance. Given the pivotal role of the Court of Justice in upholding social justice, public security and welfare, it has always held a sensitive position within the administrative framework of Islamic civilization. Rulers have consistently prioritized appointing individuals of the utmost suitability for this role. Therefore, this research endeavors to address two fundamental questions: firstly, were there specific criteria and strategies for appointing judges? If the answer is affirmative, the subsequent question pertains to the methods and processes for equipping qualified individuals for this role. This research adopts a descriptive-analytical approach and relies on library documents. it begins by tracing the historical development of the judicial role and subsequently delves into explicating the responses to these questions, drawing inspiration from texts related to the state administration. Within this context, various requirements, encompassing qualifications for sound judgment and personal attributes, have been meticulously considered by the leaders. These include elements such as field research, face-to-face interviews, reviews of past experiences, among others, aimed at achieving the most judicious selection.

Keywords

Main Subjects


  • Adine Vand, Ali Asghar and Olian, Mahdi (2015). Good urban governance in Iran: prioritizing components and knowledge. Strategy Quarterly. 25(81). pp. 305-338. (In Persian)
  • Attar Neishaburi, Faridaldin (2000). Tazkerah Alawlia .Based on the version of Reynold Allen Nicholson, with the efforts of Tavakli. Eighth edition. Tehran: Behzad Publications.(In Persian)
  • Aghili, Saif al-Din Haji bin Nizam (1985). The works of ministers. Edited by Mirjalaluddin Hosseini Ermavi (Muhadith). second edition. Tehran: Information Publications. (In Persian)
  • Ali al-Anbari, Abdul Razzaqh (1978). The position of al-Qhazi al-Qhozat in al-Abbasiya from the beginning until the end of the Seljuks era. first edition Beirut: Al-Dar al-Arabiya for Al-Morseat. (In Arabic)
  • Amin, Seyed Hassan (1382). History of Iranian law. First Edition. Tehran: Iranian Encyclopaedia Publications. (In Persian)
  • Bartold (2003). Turkestan Namah. Translated by Karim Keshavarz. Tehran: Aghaz Publications. (In Persian)
  • Bosworth, Darley Duran and Kahn, Lambton (2010). The Seljuks. Translated by Yaqhub Azhand. First Edition. Tehran: Molly Publications. (In Persian)
  • Baghdadi, Bahaoddin Mohammad ibn Moayed (1936). Al-Tavassol ela Al-Tarassol. Tehran: Ahmed Bahmanyar Publishing. (In Arabic)
  • Bayhaghi, Abulfazl. (1996). Beyhaqi history. Dr. Khalil Khatib Rahbar's efforts. Tehran: Mehtab Publications. (In Persian)
  • Dinevari, Ibn Qutaibeh (2001). Imamate and politics. Translated by Seyyed Nasser Tabatabai. Tehran: Qhoghnoos. (In Persian)
  • Fry, R.N. (2000). History of Iran. Translated by Hassan Anoushe. Third edition. Tehran: Amir Kabir Publications. (In Persian)
  • Ghazali Tusi, Imam Muhammad ibn Muhammad (1982). The King's Advice. With corrections, footnotes, comments and an introduction by Professor Jalaluddin Homayi. Tehran: Babak Publications. (In Persian)
  • Ibn Abi al-Dam, Ibrahim bin Abdullah. (1984). Judicial literature. Researched and edited by: Mohi Hilal al-Sarhan. first edition. Baghdad: Al-Ershad Press. (In Arabic)
  • Ibn Athir, Izz al-Din Ali. (1985). The complete history of Islam and Iran. Translated by Abbas Khalili (volumes 1-15) and translated by Ali Hashemi Haeri (volume 16). Tehran: Scientific Publications. (In Persian)
  • Ibn Ekhwah, Muhammad ibn Ahmad ibn Qureshi. (1988). Municipal ritual in the 7th century of Hijri (Ma'alem al-Qurba fi Ahakam-e al-Hisbah). Translated by Dr. Jafar Shaar. Third edition. Tehran: Scientific and Cultural Publishing Company. (In Persian)
  • Ibn al-Nadim, Muhammad bin Ishaq (1929). Al-Fehrest. Beirut: Dar al-Marafa. (In Arabic)
  • Ibn Balkhi. (1931). Farsnameh. Edited by Guy Lessring and Renedalene Nicholson. Tehran: Asatir. (In Persian)
  • Ibn Khaldoun, Abdor Rahman (1996). The Introduction of Ibn Khaldoun. Translated by Mohammad Parveen Gonabadi. Eighth edition. Tehran: Scientific and Cultural Publishing Company. (In Persian)
  • Ibn Khallakan, Ahmad Ibn Ibrahim. (1997). Deaths of notables and news of the sons of the time. A new revised and corrected edition, indexed by Muhammad Abd al-Rahman al-Maraashli. First Edition. Beirut: Institute of Arabic History. (In Arabic)
  • Ibn Meskaweih, Abu Ali. (1997). Experiences of nations. Translated by Alinghi Manzavi. First Edition. Tehran: Tus. (In Persian)
  • Istakhari, Ibrahim ibn Mohammad (1961). Paths and kingdoms. Beirut: Dar Sadir. (In Arabic)
  • Jahshiari, Mohammad (1969). Book of Ministers and Writers. Translated by Abulfazl Tabatabayi. Tehran: Translation and publishing. (In Persian)
  • Joyni, Mutjab al-Din Ali bin Ahmad Katab (1950). Otbah al-Kuobah. To the correction of Allameh Mohammad Qazvini and Abbas Iqbal. Tehran: Printing Company. (In Persian)
  • Kennedy, Abi Omar. (1908). The book of governors and the book of judges. Politely and correctly written by Refen Gest. Beirut: Dar al-Kutub Al-Elamiya. (In Arabic)
  • Khonoji Esfahani, Fazlullah((1985 Behavior of kings. Tehran: Kharazmi. (In Persian)
  • Lambton, A.K.A. (2001). Government and governance in Islam. Translation and research by Seyyed Abbas Salehi and Mohammad Mahdi Faqhihi. Tehran: Arouj Publishing Institute. (In Persian)
  • Masoudi, Ali ibn Hossein (1390). Meadows of gold and precious metals. Translated by Abolqasem Payandeh, Tehran: Scientific and Cultural Publishing Company. (In Persian)
  • Mawardi, Abulhasan Ali. (1985). Sultanic rulings and religious mandates. second edition. Cairo: Islamic Studies School. (In Arabic)
  • Mawardi, Abulhasan Ali (1973). Judge etiquette. Baghdad: Mohi Hilal al-Sharhan, head of Diwan al-Awqhaf. (In Arabic)
  • Metz, Adam (1983). Islamic civilization in the 4th century Hijri. Translation: Alireza Zakavati. First Edition. Tehran: Amir Kabir. (In Persian)
  • Mohagheqh Helli, Ja'far ibn Hasan (1967). The laws of Islam in matters of halal and haram. Translated by Abulqhasem ibn Ahmed Yazdi, by the effort of scholar Mohammad Taqi. Tehran: Tehran University Press. (In Persian)
  • Moqhddasi, Abu Abdullah (1906). The best divisions in knowing the regions. Beirut: Dar Sader. (In Arabic)
  • Mohaghegh, Mehdi (1995). Abolfazl Beyhaghi's memorandum. Mashhad: Ferdowsi University Press. (In Persian)
  • Moslemi, Hossein and Fazeli, Seyed Taher (2017). Strategy analysis model in the intellectual system of the Supreme Leader. Strategy Quarterly. 27(89). pp. 67-94. (In Persian)
  • Mostofi, Hamdollah (1985). selected date. Due to the attention of Dr. Abdul Hossein. (In Persian)
  • Nakhjavani, Hindushah ibn Sanjar (1979). The experiences of the predecessors. To the correction and diligence of Abbas Iqhbal Ashtiani. Third edition. Tehran: Tahuri Library. (In Persian)
  • Nizam al-Mulk Tusi, Abu Ali Hassan (1999). Policy. To the attention of Hubert Dark. fourth edition. Tehran: Scientific and Cultural Publishing Company. (In Persian)
  • Narshakhi, Muhammad ibn Jafar (1972). History of Bukhara. by the efforts of Mohammad Taghi Modares Razavi. Tehran: Toos. (In Persian)
  • Onsor-al Maali, Kikavus ibn Iskandar (1992). Qaboosnameh. To the attention of Gholamhossein Yousefi. Sixth edition. Tehran: Scientific and Cultural Publications. (In Persian)
  • Otbi, Muhammad ibn Abdul Jabbar (2003). Translation of Yamini history. Translated by Abul Sharaf Naseh bin Zafar Jarfadghani. Corrected by Jafar Shaar. Tehran: Scientific and Cultural Publishing Company. (In Persian)
  • Qodamah ibn Jafar (1996). Book of Al-Kharaj. Translation and research by Dr. Hossein Qareh Chanlou. First Edition. Tehran: Alborz Publishing. (In Persian)
  • Qalqhashandi, Ahmad ibn Ali. (1987). Sobh al-A'asha in the industry of creation. Description of Mohammad Hossein Shamsoddin. Beirut: Dar al-Kitab al-Alamiya. (In Arabic)
  • Razi, Najmoddin. (2019). Mersad al-Ebad. Tehran: Ferdous. (In Persian)
  • Rawandi, Muhammad ibn Ali ibn Soleiman (1985). Rahat al-Sodour and Ayah al-Sorour in Seljuk history. To try and correct Muhammad Iqhbal. including footnotes and indexes with the necessary corrections of the late Mohtabi Minouei. second edition. Tehran: Amir Kabir Publications. (In Persian)
  • Saket, Mohammad Hossein (2003). Proceedings in Islamic law. Tehran: Mizan Publications. (In Persian)
  • Samani, Abu Saad Abdul Karim ibn Muhammad (1980). Al-Ansab book. With the help of the Ministry of Education and Cultural Affairs of the Supreme Indian Government. first edition. Hyderabad: The Majlis of the Ottoman Encyclopaedia. (In Arabic)
  • Shpoler, Bertold (1994). History of Iran in the early Islamic centuries. Translated by Javad Flatouri. fourth edition. Tehran: Scientific and Cultural Publications. (In Persian)
  • Thaalabi Nishaboyi, Abu Mansour (1989). The News of the Persian kings and their biographies. With translation and introduction by Zattenbarak and preface by Mojtaba Minavi. Translation of the Arabic text by Mohammad Fazaeli. Tehran: Hefdeh Shahrivar Printing House. (In Persian)
  • Zahrani, Mohammad Mosfar (2013). Ministry system in the Abbasid government (Al-Buyeh and Seljuq era). The translator of Satar Oudi. Tehran: Scientific and Cultural Publications. (In Persian)
  • Zeydan, Abdul Karim (1984). Judiciary system according to Islamic law. Baghdad: Al-Ani Press. (In Arabic)
  • Zeydan ,Jurji (1994). The complete works of Jurji Zaydan.(The History of Islamic Civilization). The third edition. Beirut: Dar al-Jil. (In Arabic)
  • Watwat, Rashid (1959). Letters of Rashid al-Din and Tawat. The effort of Qasim Tuyserkani. Tehran: University of Tehran. (In Persian)